Logo

Electric Grid Automation Systems Comparison

June 15, 2021

Electric Grid Automation Systems Comparison

Welcome to our comparison guide of electric grid automation systems! If you're looking for an unbiased comparison of the most popular systems out there, you're in the right place.

What is an electric grid automation system?

Electric grid automation systems (EGAS) are designed to automate and optimize the management of electricity generation, transmission, and distribution. They help in controlling and monitoring the flow of electricity, improving the overall reliability and efficiency of the system.

Comparison Criteria

We will be comparing the following key features of the top electric grid automation systems:

  • Cost
  • Energy Efficiency
  • Programmability
  • Interoperability

Top Electric Grid Automation Systems

Let's dive in and see how they compare.

1. ABB Ability™

  • Cost: ABB Ability™ is on the higher end of the cost spectrum, with an average price tag of $500,000.
  • Energy Efficiency: ABB Ability™ boasts a high energy efficiency rating of up to 98%.
  • Programmability: ABB Ability™ is highly programmable and can be customized to meet specific needs.
  • Interoperability: ABB Ability™ is compatible with a wide range of systems, making it highly interoperable.

2. GE Grid Solutions

  • Cost: GE Grid Solutions' automation system falls in the mid-range category with a starting price of $300,000.
  • Energy Efficiency: GE Grid Solutions' energy efficiency rating is around 95%.
  • Programmability: GE Grid Solutions' automation system is programmable but not as flexible as some other systems.
  • Interoperability: GE Grid Solutions' automation system is not as interoperable as some other systems and sometimes requires custom adaptations.

3. Siemens Energy Management System

  • Cost: Siemens Energy Management System is in the higher price range, with an average price tag of $350,000.
  • Energy Efficiency: Siemens Energy Management System boasts a high energy efficiency rating of up to 99%.
  • Programmability: Siemens Energy Management System is highly programmable and can be customized to meet specific needs.
  • Interoperability: Siemens Energy Management System is highly interoperable, offering compatibility with a broad range of systems.

4. Schneider Electric EcoStruxure™ Grid

  • Cost: Schneider Electric's EcoStruxure™ Grid automation system falls in the mid-range category, with a starting price of $250,000.
  • Energy Efficiency: Schneider Electric's EcoStruxure™ Grid boasts an energy efficiency rating of around 96%.
  • Programmability: Schneider Electric's EcoStruxure™ Grid is moderately programmable and offers some customization.
  • Interoperability: Schneider Electric's EcoStruxure™ Grid is interoperable with a range of systems but less so than some other systems.

Conclusion

We hope this comparison guide has helped you get a better idea of which electric grid automation system works best for your needs. Prices and ratings may vary from case to case, but these are all great systems with unique features. It's up to you to decide which system best suits your needs and budget.

If you're interested in learning more about electric grid automation systems, we encourage you to check out these resources:

  • "Electric Grid Automation and Control Systems" by K.R. Padiyar
  • "Electric Power Systems: A Conceptual Introduction" by Alexandra von Meier
  • "Advanced Electric Power System Concepts: Theory and Applications" by K. R. Padiyar

Happy automating!

References

© 2023 Flare Compare